» Research » Reading Research Snapshots » Flattening the Developmental Staircase

Flattening the Developmental Staircase: Lexical Complexity in Elementary Reading Texts Across Six Decades

      A staircase built of flat blocks of uneven size

    Purpose

    This study examined how the lexical complexity of elementary reading textbooks has changed over six decades (1957, 1974, 1995, 2014). Using a 320,000-word corpus drawn from one continuously published core reading program (grades 1–4), the analysis investigated patterns in (a) lexical diversity (type-token ratio), (b) percentage of complex words (low-frequency and rare vocabulary), and (c) percentage of single-appearing words. The goal was to determine whether instructional texts show systematic developmental progression within and across grades—and how those patterns have shifted over time.

    Findings

    1. The developmental “staircase” has flattened. Earlier programs showed clear, systematic increases in vocabulary complexity within and across grades. Recent programs show minimal within-grade growth and sharply reduced grade-to-grade differentiation.
    2. First-grade expectations have accelerated dramatically. By 2014, first graders encountered lexical diversity levels once found in upper elementary grades.
    3. Grade-to-grade progression has compressed. In 1957, lexical diversity increased more than 100% from grade 1 to grade 2. By 2014, increases were often under 10%.
    4. Single-appearing words have increased substantially. Contemporary texts provide fewer opportunities for repetition and consolidation of vocabulary.
    5. Third and fourth grades are lexically similar. The anticipated “fourth-grade shift” is not strongly reflected in lexical measures.

    Applications

    For District Leaders & Curriculum Specialists

    
Examine whether your core program builds vocabulary complexity systematically across grades; if progression is flat, supplement with structures that ensure cumulative growth and deliberate word repetition.

    For Teacher Educators

    
Prepare beginning teachers to analyze texts beyond readability levels—attending to lexical diversity, complex vocabulary, and opportunities for consolidation.

    Bottom Line

    The issue is not declining rigor in the complexity of school texts. The issue is compressed progression. Contemporary texts often begin at elevated levels and provide less systematic lexical expectations across grades. Educational leaders, teacher educators, and teachers must ensure that vocabulary development remains cumulative, scaffolded, and developmentally coherent.